Skip to content
Stroom
Back to Blog

Guide4 min read

Design subscription or agency: which fits your product?

Project, design subscription or monthly team: what each model leaves you responsible for, what happens to quality, and how to choose.

Cover for “Design subscription or agency?”: A stack of request cards beside a single plan sheet marked with a green tick.

A founder needs the checkout redesigned before a funding round. One studio quotes a project: six weeks, one price. Another offers a subscription: a flat monthly fee, requests whenever you like, cancel when you’re done. The second looks cheaper and faster. Whether it is depends on what the founder is actually buying.

Three ways to buy design

  • A project. A scope, a timeline and a price, agreed before the work starts. The studio owns the plan: research, design, testing and handover happen in order, and the project ends.
  • A design subscription. A flat monthly fee for a queue of requests. Designjoy, one of the best-known examples, advertises one request at a time, an average delivery of about two days, and pausing or cancelling whenever you like.
  • A monthly team. Designers join your team for a monthly fee and work inside your tools and meetings on whatever the product needs next. It is closer to hiring than to ordering.

What actually differs

The pricing is the visible difference. The bigger one is who decides what gets designed.

  • In a project, the studio answers for the result. You agree the goal first, and a change of scope means a conversation.
  • In a subscription, you are the one who has to know what to ask for. Every request is a task: a landing page, a set of icons, a screen. The queue is good at finishing tasks. It doesn’t ask whether they are the right tasks.
  • In a monthly team, the decision is shared. The designers are in the planning meeting, so they can ask why before they draw the screen.

Is the quality lower?

How you pay doesn’t set the quality. Two things do: who does the work, and whether anyone studies your users first.

A request queue has no natural place for research, because research isn’t something anyone orders the way they order a screen. It doesn’t need to be big. In 2000, Jakob Nielsen argued that testing with 5 users finds about 85% of the usability problems in a design, based on his model. But somebody has to run it.

So ask any provider, subscription or agency, the same question: who talks to the users, and when?

What you keep afterwards

In 1998, Jakob Nielsen argued that a company can outsource specific pieces of its web work, such as special projects that exceed its in-house resources or need skills it doesn’t have yet, while the overall direction stays inside the company.

The GOV.UK Service Manual, the UK government’s guide to building digital services, gives the practical version. When you work with contractors, plan how their knowledge moves to your permanent team, through pairing and documentation, instead of leaving it to the last week.

Whichever model you choose, ask for three things: the source design files, the design system and the decisions, written down.

How to choose

  • Choose a subscription when you have a steady flow of small, well-defined design tasks and someone in your company who decides what to ask for.
  • Choose a project when there is one clear result with a deadline, such as a new product, a redesign or a launch, and you want the studio to answer for it, research and testing included.
  • Choose a monthly team when the product is live and the work never ends: new features, a design system to maintain, reviews before development.

At Stroom we work the last two ways: projects and a monthly team.

Don’t compare the monthly fee with the project price. Compare what each one leaves you responsible for. A subscription sells you finished tasks and leaves the thinking with you. A project sells you a result. A monthly team sells you people who share the thinking. Pick the one that matches who, in your company, knows what should be designed next.

Sources

Questions

What is the difference between a design subscription and a project-based agency?

A design subscription charges a flat monthly fee for a queue of design requests, usually handled one at a time, and you decide what to ask for. A project-based agency agrees a scope, timeline and price up front and answers for the result, research and testing included.

How does the quality of subscription-based design services compare with traditional agencies?

How you pay does not set the quality. It depends on who does the work and whether anyone studies your users first. A request queue suits well-defined tasks; work that needs research, testing and decisions across a whole product fits a project or an embedded team better.

When does a monthly design team make more sense than a subscription?

When the product is live and the design work never stops: new features, a design system to maintain and reviews before development. Designers who join your tools and meetings share the decisions, where a subscription only carries out the requests you write.

All articles

  • Cover for “What is user experience?”: A person and a dashed blue path through two screens to a goal marked with a green tick.

    Guide4 min read

    What is user experience?

    User experience in plain words: how it differs from UI, what the work involves, from research to testing, and an everyday example.

  • Cover for “What good UX\nis worth to a business”: A report sheet with rising bars and an orange line going up, with a green tick on its corner.

    Why like this?5 min read

    What good UX is worth to a business

    What McKinsey, Baymard and Forrester actually measured about UX and conversion, revenue, support costs, rework and retention.

Let’s start your project

Tell us about your product and what you are trying to achieve, and we will get in touch to plan the next step.

Start your project

To get started, what do you need?

Choose what fits your product today and we’ll guide you step by step.