Skip to content
Stroom
Back to Blog

Why like this?4 min read

Why do you push a door that says pull?

It isn’t you, it’s the door. On handles that say one thing while the door does another, and what that means for every button on a screen.

Cover for “Why do you push a door\nthat says pull?”: A paper door with a blue push bar under a pull sign; a cursor pushes the bar and a red cross marks it wrong.

You walk up to a glass door with a metal bar across its middle. You lean in and push. Nothing. You glance down and find a small sign: PULL.

It isn’t you. It’s the door.

A door with a name

In The Design of Everyday Things (first published in 1988), the cognitive scientist Don Norman wrote about these doors so memorably that they now carry his name: the “Norman door”. It is any door whose shape tells you one thing while it works another way.

The idea is simple: objects speak through their shape before we read a single word.

  • A handle says: grab me and pull.
  • A flat plate says: push me.
  • A visible hinge says: this is the side that swings.

Norman calls these cues signifiers: what people see that tells them what to do, without thinking. When something needs a sign to explain how it opens, its design has not done its job.

The same problem on a screen

We meet Norman doors on screens every day:

  • Text that looks like a link but does nothing when you tap it.
  • A flat button with no border or fill that reads like a heading.
  • A whole card that looks tappable, when only a small arrow in its corner responds.
  • An icon with no label, which people guess at and then give up on.

In each case the user blames themselves, just as you did at the entrance, and then leaves.

The takeaway

Make the shape say the action: what can be tapped looks tappable, and what can’t doesn’t pretend to be. If you need instructions to explain how something works, change the design first.

Sources

Questions

What is a Norman door?

One whose shape suggests one action while it needs another, like a pull handle you have to push. It is named after the cognitive scientist Don Norman, who wrote about them in The Design of Everyday Things (first published in 1988).

What is a signifier?

A visible cue that tells people what to do without thinking: a handle says pull, a flat plate says push. On a screen, signifiers show what can be tapped.

How do you avoid Norman doors on a screen?

Make the shape say the action: links look like links, buttons look like buttons, and nothing that looks tappable ignores a tap.

All articles

  • Cover for “What is user experience?”: A person and a dashed blue path through two screens to a goal marked with a green tick.

    Guide4 min read

    What is user experience?

    User experience in plain words: how it differs from UI, what the work involves, from research to testing, and an everyday example.

  • Cover for “What good UX\nis worth to a business”: A report sheet with rising bars and an orange line going up, with a green tick on its corner.

    Why like this?5 min read

    What good UX is worth to a business

    What McKinsey, Baymard and Forrester actually measured about UX and conversion, revenue, support costs, rework and retention.

Let’s start your project

Tell us about your product and what you are trying to achieve, and we will get in touch to plan the next step.

Start your project

To get started, what do you need?

Choose what fits your product today and we’ll guide you step by step.